Supergirl 2026 Review: A Hero Who Does Not Want The Power, A Movie That Does Not Want To Be Supergirl
F'nAround movies review. Spoilers for Supergirl, 2026, because you cannot talk about why it works and why it does not work without talking about the ending, the villain, and the dog. I finally watched it, on HBO Max, with Mike, and we hit pause a dozen times to argue about comic lore, about DC history, and about whether any of this lines up. That is not a complaint. That pausing, that debating, that stopping the movie to say, wait, that is not how that works, was the most fun part of the night. The movie itself was the hard part.
Here is my verdict up front, so you do not have to wait for it. Supergirl is not a bad idea. It is a bad fit, for this character, at this moment, in this universe. It takes a white knight, a character who is supposed to be Superman's cousin and his sometimes and almost moral equal, and it tries to make her into a Guardians of the Galaxy misfit, a drunk, a runaway, a reluctant avenger, and then it asks kids who are just getting into superheroes to follow her into a story about human trafficking, revenge killing, and grief. That is dark, and it is far, too far for a first solo Supergirl movie, and I can see why it bombed. I can also see why Krypto stole the show, why Lobo should have had more screen time, and why, even though it ends nicely, it feels like a dead end. Mike believes it killed the James Gunn universe. I am not ready to say it killed it, because Gunn is still making Man of Tomorrow, but I understand why Mike feels that way, because this movie feels like a universe trying to be clever before it has earned the right to be dark.
Supergirl 2026: The Basics, The Cast, And The Last Time We Saw Her
Supergirl is a 2026 American superhero film, directed by Craig Gillespie, written by Ana Nogueira, produced by James Gunn and Peter Safran for DC Studios, and it is the second film in the DC Universe, the DCU, after Superman in 2025. It premiered June 22, 2026 in Brooklyn, opened in the United States June 26, 2026, runs 108 minutes, is rated PG-13, and went to digital July 28, 2026 and to HBO Max September 10, 2026, which is how we watched it, at home, with a pause button, which turned out to be essential.
The cast is strong on paper, and that is part of the frustration, because the movie does not give most of them enough to do. Milly Alcock, best known as young Rhaenyra Targaryen in House of the Dragon, plays Kara Zor-El, Supergirl. Eve Ridley, from 3 Body Problem, plays Ruthye Marye Knoll, the teenage girl who recruits Kara. Matthias Schoenaerts, from Rust and Bone and Red Sparrow, plays Krem of the Yellow Hills, the villain. Jason Momoa plays Lobo, the bounty hunter. David Krumholtz plays Zor-El, Kara's father. Emily Beecham plays Alura In-Ze, Kara's mother. David Corenswet returns as Superman, Clark Kent, in a cameo that is really a check in, a cousin worried about his cousin, and a reminder of what this universe is supposed to feel like.
My last memory of Supergirl, before James Gunn's version, was the CW show, with Melissa Benoist playing Kara for six seasons, from 2015 to 2021, first on CBS and then on the CW, as part of the Arrowverse. That Supergirl was earnest, hopeful, funny, and a little clumsy, and she was a hero kids could look up to without needing a trigger warning. Before that, there was Helen Slater in Supergirl in 1984, the first solo Supergirl movie, and Sasha Calle in The Flash in 2023, in the old DC Extended Universe, which Warner Bros. shut down after a string of flops. Gunn and Safran were hired to reset all of that, to build a new DCU from scratch, and Superman in 2025 was the first step, a breath of fresh air, 83 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, 618.7 million dollars worldwide, and a Krypto who stole every scene he was in. Supergirl was supposed to be the second step. It was not. It was a stumble, and a costly one.
The Premise: A Birthday Pub Crawl, A Poisoned Dog, And A Girl Who Wants Revenge
The premise, as adapted from Tom King and Bilquis Evely's Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow, the eight issue limited series from 2021 to 2022, is simple, and in the comic it is powerful. Kara is celebrating her birthday, in the comic her 21st, in the film her 23rd, by drinking her way across the galaxy, visiting planets with red suns, where her Kryptonian powers fade and she can actually feel drunk, and feel ordinary, for a while. She is with Krypto, her dog, who is rambunctious, destructive, and loyal, and who is, in both Superman and Supergirl, the best part of the movie.
Into that bar walks Ruthye Marye Knoll, a teenage girl, the last survivor of her family, who watched Krem of the Yellow Hills and his Brigands murder her father, Elias Knoll, a renowned sword maker, and slaughter her family. Ruthye wants a warrior to help her hunt Krem and kill him. Kara says no. She does not want the job, she does not want the responsibility, and she does not want to be a hero that night. She wants to drink.
Then Krem steals Kara's ship, and shoots Krypto with a poison dart, a slow acting poison that gives the dog three days to live, unless Kara gets the antidote from Krem. Now Kara has a reason, and it is not a noble reason. It is a personal reason. Save the dog, get the antidote, and while she is at it, help Ruthye, because Ruthye is not going to stop, with or without her. What follows is a revenge quest across the galaxy, from planet to planet, chasing Krem and his Brigands, and learning, along the way, that revenge is not justice, and that grief does not go away just because you kill the person who caused it.
That is the comic, and the comic is widely regarded as one of the best Supergirl stories ever, nominated for an Eisner for Best Limited Series, because it is about grief, revenge, sisterhood, and forgiveness, and because Ruthye narrates it like a folk legend, seeing Supergirl through her eyes, at a remove, as a mythic figure who is flawed and human. The movie keeps the broad strokes, but it changes the ending, it changes the tone, and it adds Lobo, who was not in the comic at all, and those changes matter, because they take away the emotional punch that made the comic work.
Comic Lore: Who Kara Is, Why She Is Not Clark, And Why That Matters
To understand why this movie feels wrong, you have to understand who Kara is in the comics, and why she is different from Clark, and why that difference is the whole point of her character. Kara Zor-El first appeared in Action Comics 252 in May 1959, created by Otto Binder and Al Plastino, as Superman's cousin from Krypton, the Girl of Steel, the Maid of Might, the Last Daughter of Krypton, depending on the era. She is not just a female Superman. She is a Superman who remembers Krypton, and that changes everything.
Clark was sent to Earth as a baby, raised by loving parents, Jonathan and Martha Kent, in Smallville, with no memory of Krypton. He grew up human, with human values, and he became Superman because he was raised to be good. Kara was raised on Krypton, on a fragment of Krypton, Argo City, after her father Zor-El saved a chunk of the planet with a force field. She watched everyone around her die, slowly, from radiation poisoning, for the first 14 years of her life, and then she came to Earth as a teenager, already formed, already grieving, already angry. Gunn himself said this when he announced the DCU, that Kara is much more hardcore, that she is not exactly the Supergirl we are used to seeing, because she watched her world die in terrible ways.
That backstory is real, and it is powerful, and it is why a darker Supergirl can work, in the comics, when it is handled with care. In Woman of Tomorrow, Kara's power is not action, it is restraint, endurance, and passion, as Ruthye says at the end. She does not kill Krem, even when she wants to. She banishes him to the Phantom Zone for 300 years, and 300 years later, in the epilogue, she and an elderly Ruthye free him, and he is repentant, and Ruthye whacks him in the head with her cane, and they walk off together. That is a story about forgiveness, not revenge, and it works because it is slow, and because it is told by Ruthye, who learns, over months, that killing is not justice.
The movie compresses that months long journey into three days, because Krypto is dying, and it makes Kara kill, or at least it makes the ending about killing, not about sparing, and that changes the moral. It also makes Kara's trauma into a drinking problem, a party girl problem, a I do not want to be a hero problem, and it never really earns the turn from that to heroism, because it never really builds her up as a hero in the first place. You cannot dirty the mantle until you have built the character, and this movie tries to dirty it first, and build it later, and that is backwards.
The Dark Part: Sex Trafficking In A Superhero Movie, And Why I Would Never Do That
Here is the part I struggled with most, and I want to be plain about it, because it is not a small thing, and it is not a spoiler you can skip. The Brigands, Krem's gang, are not just space pirates. In the film, they are human traffickers. They kidnap young women to force them to be their brides. That is the plot, stated in the film's own summary, and it is not subtle. On the planet Bilquis, Kara and Ruthye learn from a local couple, Bomar and Mareck, that the Brigands have been taking young women, including their daughter Sarna, and Mareck tries to drug Kara to trade her and Ruthye to the Brigands in exchange for Sarna. Later, Ruthye is kidnapped and taken to the Brigands' ship, where Lobo is also imprisoned, and Kara, with Lobo's help, defeats the Brigands and frees the captive women on board.
I would never want to do a movie about sex trafficking in the superhero genre. It was dark, and it was far, too far, for a character like Supergirl, and for an audience that includes kids who are just getting into superheroes. Supergirl is supposed to be a white knight, like Superman, a symbol of hope, and you do not introduce her, in her first solo movie in the new universe, by making her fight sex traffickers, and by making a teenage girl watch her family get murdered, and by making a mother try to trade two girls to save her own daughter. That is not a superhero movie. That is a crime drama with a cape on it, and it does not work, because the movie is too glib, too jokey, too Guardians of the Galaxy, to handle a subject that serious with the weight it deserves. One reviewer put it well, that the film's glibness often undercuts the seriousness of this aspect of the story, and that is exactly right. You cannot make a joke about a drunk Supergirl in one scene, and then ask the audience to take sex trafficking seriously in the next, and expect them to follow you. The tone breaks, and once it breaks, it does not come back.
In the comic, the Brigands are horrible too, but they are horrible in a different way. They kill whole races of people, they leave genocides in their wake, and the theme is that what they have done is too big for one person to manage, too big for revenge to fix. That is a big, cosmic, mythic horror, and it fits a superhero story, because it is about scale, not about a specific, real world crime that is in the news every day. The movie changes them to sex traffickers, and that makes them smaller, and more real, and more upsetting, in a way that does not fit a PG-13 space adventure, and that does not fit a character who is supposed to be a beacon. I understand why the filmmakers wanted a villain who was worthy of Supergirl's time, but I do not think this was the way to do it. There are other ways to make a villain terrible without making the movie about trafficking. This movie chose the wrong one.
With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility, And Kara Does Not Want Either
Mike said it best, while we were watching, and we paused the movie to talk about it, because it was the clearest line in the whole night. Remember in Spider-Man, with great power comes great responsibility. This is the epitome of a superhero who does not want the power or the responsibility. This is a superhero who gave up for a while and lost her way.
Mike is right, and that line is the whole movie, in one sentence. Kara does not want to be Supergirl. She wants to drink, she wants to party, she wants to be on a red sun planet where she is not special, where she is not strong, where she is not responsible for anybody. She is not Clark, who embraces the cape, who wants to help, who sees power as a duty. She is Kara, who sees power as a burden, who sees responsibility as a trap, and who has given up, for a while, because giving up is easier than carrying the weight of Krypton on your shoulders every day.
That could be a powerful story, if the movie earned it, if it showed us why she gave up, and what it would take for her to come back. But the movie does not earn it. It tells us she is traumatized, it shows us a flashback to Argo City dying, it shows us her father Zor-El, played by David Krumholtz, sending her away, and it expects us to fill in the rest. It does not show us her building a life on Earth, it does not show us her learning to be a hero, it does not show us her choosing, slowly, to come back. It shows us a drunk girl in a bar, and then a girl chasing a poison antidote, and then a girl in a suit, punching a villain, and it calls that a character arc. It is not. It is a plot, with a character attached to it, and the character never really changes, because she never really chooses to change. She is dragged into heroism by a dying dog and a teenage girl who will not take no for an answer, and that is not the same as wanting to be a hero.
They nerfed her, and they nerfed her hard. That is my phrase, and I mean it in the gaming sense, and in the comic sense. She spends most of the movie without her powers, on red sun planets, or poisoned, or weakened, or beaten up, and when she finally gets her full powers back, under a yellow sun, in the third act, it feels like a cheat, not a triumph, because we have not seen her earn it. We have seen her lose, over and over, and then we see her win, once, at the end, and we are supposed to cheer. I did not cheer. I felt relieved, because the movie was almost over, and because Krypto was going to live, and because Ruthye was going to live, but I did not feel like I had watched a superhero become a superhero. I felt like I had watched a superhero get dragged, kicking and screaming, into a fight she did not want, and then get a win she did not really earn.
Lobo: Jason Momoa Was Made For The Role, And Then They Wasted Him
I was super excited for Lobo, and I am not embarrassed to say that. Lobo is a comic legend, the Main Man, the Last Czarnian, an intergalactic bounty hunter who is violent, unpredictable, funny, and completely unhinged, and Jason Momoa was made for the role. He is big, he is loud, he is funny, he is scary, and he has the exact energy Lobo needs, which is a guy who will kill you, and then make a joke about it, and then kill your friend too, if you pay him enough. Momoa played Aquaman in the old DC universe, and he was good, but Lobo is a better fit for him, because Lobo does not have to be noble. He just has to be Lobo.
Like Blanka in Street Fighter, they oversold him and his screen time. In Street Fighter, Momoa played Blanka, and the trailers made it look like he was a main character, and he was not, he was a side character with a few scenes, and that was disappointing, because Momoa is a star, and Blanka is a fan favorite. In Supergirl, they did the same thing, but worse, because Lobo is even more important to the marketing, and even more absent from the movie. Do not get me wrong, compared to Street Fighter, he was the star of this movie, when he was on screen, he was the best part, he was funny, he was violent, he was Momoa, and he made the movie better just by showing up. But he should have had more. He should have had a whole movie, or at least a whole act, not a few scenes where he shows up, fights, gets captured, gets freed by Ruthye, and then helps Kara fight the Brigands, and then leaves. That is not a Lobo movie. That is a Lobo cameo, with a trailer that promised a Lobo movie.
Lobo was not in the Tom King comic at all, which tells you something. He was added for the film, because the filmmakers knew Momoa would sell tickets, and because they knew Lobo would test well, and according to reports, his role was boosted during reshoots, because he tested well and warranted more screen time. That is the problem, in one sentence. He was added to sell the movie, not to serve the story, and when you add a character to sell a movie, you do not give him a story, you give him a trailer, and the audience can tell the difference. I loved every minute Momoa was on screen, and I wanted more, and that wanting more is the best and worst thing about his performance. Best, because he is that good. Worst, because the movie knows he is that good, and it still does not give him enough to do.
Krypto Stole The Show, Again, And David Krumholtz Raised My Nostalgia
Of course Krypto stole the show, in both Superman and Supergirl, and of course he did, because he is a dog, and he is a super dog, and he is rambunctious, destructive, loyal, and funny, and he is the only character in either movie who does not have trauma, or a drinking problem, or a revenge quest. He just wants to play, and to be loved, and to save the day by being a dog, and that is refreshing, in a universe that is trying so hard to be dark and serious and grown up. In Superman, Krypto was a scene stealer. In Supergirl, he is the plot, because he is poisoned, and Kara has three days to save him, and that is the only reason she agrees to help Ruthye in the first place. Without Krypto, there is no movie. With Krypto, there is a movie, but it is a movie about a dog, not about a superhero, and that tells you something about where the heart of this film really is.
We loved that her Kryptonian father was from Harold and Kumar and other childhood favorites like Addams Family Values, and I mean that, because David Krumholtz as Zor-El is the most human part of the movie, even though he is only in it for a few minutes, in flashback, on Argo City. Krumholtz played Goldstein, Seth Goldstein, in Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle in 2004, and in the sequels, and he played Joel Glicker, the boy Wednesday Addams falls for, in Addams Family Values in 1993, and he played Bernard the elf in The Santa Clause, and Charlie Eppes in Numb3rs, and Isidor Isaac Rabi in Oppenheimer in 2023. He is one of those actors you have seen a dozen times without knowing his name, and then you realize, oh, that guy, I love that guy, and he is Zor-El, and he is sending his daughter away from a dying world, and he is doing it with love, and with grief, and with a speech that is the highlight of the film for a lot of reviewers. That speech, that moment, is the only time the movie feels like a Superman family story, and not like a Guardians of the Galaxy knockoff, and it is over too soon, because Krumholtz is only in the movie for a few minutes, and then he is gone, and we are back to bars and bounty hunters and Brigands.
Emily Beecham as Alura, Kara's mother, is also good, in the same brief way, and together, Krumholtz and Beecham make Argo City feel real, in a way the rest of the movie does not. They make Krypton feel like a place with a family, not just a planet that exploded. That is what the movie needed more of, and what it did not give us enough of. More family, less bar crawl. More Krypton, less red sun drinking. More heart, less Guardians.
James Gunn Tried To Guardians Of The Galaxy Supergirl, And It Does Not Work
Mike believes he tried to Guardians of the Galaxy Supergirl and it does not work, and Mike is right, and here is why. James Gunn made Guardians of the Galaxy work at Marvel because the Guardians were misfits, nobodies, a raccoon, a tree, a green assassin, a muscle bound idiot, and a human who was kidnapped as a kid. They were not white knights. They were criminals, and losers, and they became heroes by accident, and by choice, over three movies, and the jokes, the needle drops, the irreverence, fit them, because they were not supposed to be noble. They were supposed to be funny, and messy, and human, in the worst way, and then they grew up.
Supergirl is not a Guardian. Supergirl is like Superman, a white knight, outside of comic lore, you do not dirty the mantle until you have built the character. That is Mike's line, and it is the smartest line in this review, because it is true for Superman, and it is true for Supergirl, and it is true for any character who is supposed to be a symbol. You do not start with the dirty version. You start with the clean version, you build the symbol, you make the audience love the symbol, and then, later, when the audience trusts you, you can dirty it, you can complicate it, you can make it darker, and the audience will follow you, because they know what the character is supposed to be, and they know you are testing it, not replacing it. Think of Kevin Kostner in Man of Steel holding his hand up.
Gunn did the opposite. He started with the dirty version, a drunk Kara, a Kara who does not want to be a hero, a Kara who is jaded and angry and lost, and he expected the audience to love her, without ever showing them the clean version, without ever building the mantle in the first place. That works in the comic, because the comic is for people who already know Supergirl, who already love her, and who are ready for a darker take. It does not work in a movie, for kids who are just getting into superheroes, and for a general audience whose last memory of Supergirl was the CW show, where she was hopeful and earnest, and where she was a hero kids could look up to. You cannot ask a new audience to love a dirty version of a character they have not met yet. You have to introduce her first, as a hero, and then you can complicate her. Gunn skipped the introduction, and went straight to the complication, and the audience, and the box office, said no.
The Box Office, The Reviews, And Why It Bombed
I can see why it bombed, and the numbers are not close, and they are not kind. Supergirl opened June 26, 2026, to 37.1 million dollars in North America, against tracking of around 55 million, and 62.6 million dollars globally in its opening weekend, finishing a distant second to Toy Story 5. It fell by more than 70 percent in its second weekend, one of the steepest drops for any superhero release, and it shed more than 1,000 theaters heading into its third week. It finished its theatrical run at about 126.4 million dollars worldwide, against a production budget reported at 170 to 186 million dollars, before marketing, which was reported at about 120 million dollars. That makes it a box office bomb, by any definition, with reported losses ranging from about 85 million dollars to about 135 million dollars, depending on the source and whether you count home entertainment, and with a break even point reported at around 300 million dollars, which it never came close to.
The reviews did not rescue it. Critics landed at 52 to 58 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, depending on when you check, with audiences kinder at 72 to 77 percent, Metacritic at 50, labeled mixed, and CinemaScore at B minus. Superman, by comparison, held 83 percent on Rotten Tomatoes with a 90 percent audience score, and grossed 618.7 million dollars worldwide. Supergirl is the lowest grossing DC film in more than two decades, and it is now set to be overtaken at the box office by Clayface, a body horror film that opened October 23, 2026, with 78 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, which tells you how far the DCU has fallen, in just a few months, from Superman to Supergirl to Clayface, and how much the audience has moved on.
There is a twist, and it is worth mentioning, because it is part of why we watched it at home. Supergirl was a streaming hit on HBO Max, after it arrived September 10, 2026. It was the number one movie on HBO Max worldwide after a month, with 304 million minutes viewed in the United States in its first four days, according to Nielsen, and it stayed in the top three worldwide for a month. That does not erase the box office bomb label, and it does not make the movie profitable, but it does mean people were curious, and they watched it at home, where they could pause, and discuss, and debate, like Mike and I did, and where the movie did not have to be a 170 million dollar gamble. It could just be a movie, on a couch, with a dog, and a pause button, and that is a better way to watch it, even if it is not a better movie.
It Ends Nicely, And Sadly, Not Much Else To Say, Because We Will Not See More
Of course it ends nicely, and sadly, not much else to say, because we will not ever see more in this universe, at least not in the way we hoped we would. Kara saves Krypto, Ruthye gets her revenge, or at least her justice, Krem is dealt with, the captive women are freed, Lobo rides off, Superman checks in, and Kara goes to Earth, with her dog, and with a little more hope than she had at the start. That is a nice ending, and it is a sad ending, because it feels like a goodbye, not a hello. It feels like a movie that knows it is the end of something, not the start of something, and it wraps up neatly, because it has to, because there is no guarantee of a sequel, and because the audience, and the studio, have already moved on.
Mike believes this killed the James Gunn universe, and I understand why he believes that, because Supergirl was the second true film in the DCU, and if the second film bombs this hard, it is fair to ask, what is the third film going to be, and who is going to pay for it, and who is going to show up. But I have to be fair, and say what is actually true, not just what it feels like. Gunn has said Milly Alcock has not been fired as Supergirl, calling that claim one that could not be more false in October 2026, and she is still expected in Man of Tomorrow on July 9, 2027, with David Corenswet back as Superman and Nicholas Hoult back as Lex Luthor. DC Studios co chief Peter Safran has said he remains confident in the slate, and that Supergirl, while it did not meet box office expectations, is just one component of a broader, long term strategy. That may be spin, and it may be true, and it may be both, but it is not a cancellation. The universe is not dead, officially. It is wounded, and it is on life support, and it is going to need Man of Tomorrow to be a hit, or it will be dead, in practice, if not in name. They did lose their jobs over all of this though.
That is the sad part, and it is the part Mike and I kept coming back to, while we were pausing the movie to talk about comic lore. We love these characters. We love Supergirl, we love Superman, we love Lobo, we love Krypto, and we want a DC universe that works, that builds characters before it dirties them, that earns its darkness, that does not try to Guardians of the Galaxy a white knight, and that does not make a movie about sex trafficking and call it a superhero adventure for kids. This movie did not do that, and it paid for it, at the box office, and in the reviews, and in the way it feels, like a movie that tried to be clever, and ended up being sad, and a little bit lost, just like Kara herself.
Final verdict, in one line, because that is all this movie really deserves, after all that pausing and debating: Supergirl is a hero who does not want the power, in a movie that does not want to be Supergirl, with a dog who steals the show, a bounty hunter who should have had more, a father who should have had more, and an ending that is nice, and sad, because we will probably never see this version again. Watch it on HBO Max, with a friend, with a pause button, and with a lot of comic lore to argue about. Do not watch it expecting a new DC universe. Watch it expecting a cautionary tale, about what happens when you try to make a white knight into a Guardian, before you have built the knight in the first place.