New Paradise Bakery & Gelato One of Chicago’s Best Italian Bakeries
New Paradise Bakery & Gelato One of Chicago’s Best Italian Bakeries
If you’re searching for authentic Italian pastries in Chicago, fresh cannoli, arancini, gelato, affogato, Italian cookies, custom cakes, and traditional Sicilian desserts, New Paradise Bakery & Gelato should be on your list.
Located at 5742 N. Milwaukee Avenue in Chicago’s Gladstone Park neighborhood, New Paradise Bakery has built a reputation as one of the city’s premier Italian bakeries. Whether you’re stopping in for a morning espresso and pastry, ordering a custom celebration cake, or picking up desserts for a family gathering, this place consistently delivers quality.
One of our favorite items is their incredible selection of Italian pastries. From classic cannoli and sfogliatelle to cookies, tarts, and specialty desserts, everything looks as good as it tastes. Their display cases are packed with traditional Italian sweets that immediately transport you to an old-world bakery experience.
The arancini deserve special recognition. These crispy Sicilian rice balls are packed with flavor and make the perfect savory complement to all the sweet treats available throughout the bakery. They are among the best we’ve had in Chicago and are worth the trip alone.
Their gelato selection is equally impressive, offering rich flavors and a creamy texture that rivals many dedicated gelato shops. If you’re visiting, don’t leave without ordering an affogato. The combination of fresh espresso poured over gelato creates one of the most satisfying Italian desserts you can find anywhere in the city.
New Paradise Bakery has also become a familiar sight at Chicago’s Festa Italiana on Taylor Street, where many visitors have enjoyed their desserts, pastries, and refreshing affogatos while celebrating Italian culture, food, and traditions.
We’ve visited for birthday celebrations and special occasions over the years, and their cakes have always impressed. Whether you’re looking for a birthday cake, graduation cake, wedding desserts, Italian cookies, pastry trays, or catering for a family event, they offer a wide variety of options.
What stands out just as much as the food is the people. The owners are welcoming, the employees are friendly, and the atmosphere reflects the family-oriented hospitality that makes neighborhood bakeries special.
Chicago has no shortage of bakeries, but New Paradise Bakery & Gelato continues to stand out through quality ingredients, authentic Italian recipes, outstanding customer service, and a menu that successfully balances traditional Sicilian flavors with modern favorites.
If you’re looking for one of the best Italian bakeries in Chicago, authentic cannoli, fresh sfogliatelle, homemade gelato, arancini, Italian cakes, Italian cookies, espresso drinks, affogato, pastry trays, dessert catering, or a neighborhood bakery worth visiting, New Paradise Bakery & Gelato is absolutely worth the stop.
Address: 5742 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago, IL 60646
Whether you’re a longtime customer or discovering it for the first time, come hungry and save room for dessert.
New Paradise Bakery Chicago,IL | Italian Pastries, Gelato, Custom Cakes.
5742 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago,
IL 60646
Newparadisebakery.com
Hours open 8 am - 6 pm Tuesday through Saturday
8 am - 4 pm Sunday and Monday
Call ahead to guarantee yourself an arancini ball (773) 993-0262
They showcase their items on Instagram
@newparadisebakery
